It's been a while since any of the heads have contributed our comic book know-how to old Al's information superhighway. Things did get a bit busy there for a while, but still, we ought not have let you, our adoring public, go so long without those opinions you crave. I mean, how many days have we ruined by depriving some down on their luck web surfer the opportunity for a little levity and profanity by way of ol' RHD's (semi-)drunken ramblings? Well, times be a changing again and we're bring it back...old school.
For my part, I've got a whole jumble of thoughts rollicking around in this wizened noggin, causing me to almost seize up when confronted with the prospect of writing anything down. Imagine the opposite of an aphasia and that might be about what it's been like. Consequently, I've opted to start a new column in which I can pretty much let loose and write in a less orderly manner than I typically prefer, just so as to get it all out there in something approaching a coherent form. Over the next few weeks I'll work most everything out as I give my thoughts on the last few months of comic-ing that has been so woefully under-covered by everyone's favorite three-headed dog. It's gonna be a wild ride, so hold on as you plunge into the depths of cenTrale's mind. (On a related note: I have yet to come up with a title for this new column. I was thinking maybe “cenTrifugal Force” or “cenTrale's Cranial EsCapades” or something. Suggestions are more than welcome.)
Let's begin in a quasi-alphabetical manner with an obsession near and dear to my thrice-shared heart: Aquaman. By now you should all know that the revamped Aquaman: Sword of Atlantis has been canceled. Or maybe you don't know that and this is the first time you've heard about Aquaman or his comic since, well, I last wrote about it back in June. Given how things have gone since – they got worse – you've probably spared yourself quite a bit of pain. Seriously.
I remain flummoxed, though, at how little folks seem to care about this guy, despite his years of existence and the relatively light use that has been made of him. You've got a character that for all intents and purposes does not share a world with the rest of the DC characters: he's under the sea (cue a singing crab) and they're all mucking about on the surface, wandering into one another's cities and generally pissing each other off with mind-wipes, crises of conscience, and universe threatening events. So, yeah, the stakes may seem to be higher for the wider set of DC heroes, yet there exists a shared continuity that is almost always going to be frustrating and imprecise. Aquaman, meanwhile, by virtue of where he spends the majority of his time and the relatively light use of the character is effectively a carte blanche. Do with him as you will and the odds are good that you won't be treading on too many toes. Seriously, the Green Arrow gets more attention than Aquaman, and that was even while Ollie was dead.
But, you know what? My Aquaman history isn't perfect. I know the detailed facts, but have yet to read all of the comics and therefore can't say for sure what the qualified information is: the kind of interactions that took place, the precise relationship between Aquaman and the other heroes, how well he's been written in the past and how consistent that writing has been. I just don't know. What I do know, however, is the recent history, Sword of Atlantis. And I have to say, as a fan of comics and someone who has always had a soft spot in his heart for Aquaman (and Namor...I don't know why I like these characters but clearly I've got some kind of watery fixation...let's not delve too deeply into this one), the treatment of the revamped Aquaman has been atrocious.
The decision to revamp the series with a new name and protagonist and the decision to end it due to poor sales both came out of the same appropriate thought process: giving the series a shot. It's been clear for some time that folks don't really give a crap about this character and the fact that he appears in pop culture as a joke doesn't really help his case any. So, take the concept, tweak it a bit, and allow the book to (forgive me for saying this) sink or swim on its own. Again, there isn't much I disagree with here. Personally, I'd have had no problem had they simply kept things the same with the old Aquaman working to restore the peace and prosperity of the undersea kingdoms in the wake of Atlantis' destruction, but I was also fine with following this new kid as he worked to do the same, but with pretty much no idea of how things were before and what to expect around the next reef or at the end of a current. On top of all that Busiek and Guice were absolutely nailing it, providing a strong narrative and anchoring the characters in Aqua-history while leaving things free and clear to develop in new directions. What they started could, had the numbers held up, have led to easily 60 issues of story before they really needed to adjust things again, maybe reestablish Atlantis or shake up the status quo in some new manner. But the numbers didn't hold up and it became necessary to kill the book. Again, this all follows from the initial premise. The problem is that the lagging numbers had, as far as I'm concerned, little to do with the core concepts behind the book and everything in the world to do with the change in creative team. Maybe the book would have failed anyway, but it sure as hell would not have pissed me off quite so much by the end had Tad Williams and Shawn McManus not graced its pages.
I'll start with McManus because I at least respect him and, in truth, what happened was really nowhere near as much his fault as it was Williams'. It was quite startling to flip through Absolute Sandman Vol. 2 and discover that the artist for the “A Game of You” arc was McManus. Hell, he even drew “Three Septembers and a January” one of my favorite issues in the entire run. The art was perfect throughout and perfectly fit the stories being told. So I say I was startled because I hate (def.: pure, blind, seething rage aroused by the site of the artist's work in a specific context) his work on Aquaman. Everyone just looks deformed. I mentioned in a previous review the elongated jaws and how annoying they are and, well, they remained annoying. Towards the end I still hated the art but could tolerate it enough that I stopped trying to gouge out my eyes upon opening the book. Maybe I got used to it or maybe Tad Williams' scripts broke me. I dunno. Some blame obviously needs to be placed on the colorist as there is no difference between the underwater scenarios and those on dry land, but hey, I've only got so much vitriol to expend. So, yeah, the art sucked and that certainly hurt the book. On the other hand, nothing could have saved it from Tad Williams, so no harm no foul Shawn.
Tad, on the other hand, much like Lucy has some 'splainin' to do. I can only assume he was brought in because of his fantasy/sci-fi credentials. Surely he'd have a good idea of how to keep the sword-and-sorcery vibe going, right? Er, no, not really. Within an issue or two all that was done and over with. In fact, we spent the last couple issues dealing with a conspiracy to destroy much of the world via some pseudo-scientific attack on fault lines that would result in a displaced Atlantean taking control of the population that survived on in the water (a mutagen was going to be introduced to change people and give them a chance at surviving underwater...or something) while none other than Vandal Savage took over the dry land. That's right: Vandal Savage. Just how many plots does this guy have going at once? Could we use some other crazed villain that looks like a caveman instead? It's just that I feel like the character is best when underutilized and he's already been in JSA recently and...I hate you Tad Williams.
But there was a sorcery edge to all of it with a scary conspiracy and the return of Tempest in a much reduced and weakened form that, given the series cancellation, will NOT BE ANSWERED ANYTIME SOON!!! Yeah, that leaves a really good taste in the mouth. Let's alter course so drastically that from one issue to another the whole damn series is all but unrecognizable and then, just for the hell of it, let's throw in a bunch of cameos by the other members of the JLA just so we can have them in a couple of panels not knowing what to make of the dead Aquaman (Oh, I forgot to mention didn't I? They offed the Dweller (the original Aquaman) within two issues.) and just look goofy underwater (not that they looked any different than had they been drawn on land I suppose). Not to mention the fact that the series seemed to be taking aim at removing the surface world from the equation for a while just so as to firmly establish that whole “underwater-epic” thing. Guess Tad didn't get the memo. Back to the action though and now we have Cyborg thrown into the mix along with the Human Flying Fish (a character from back in the day) but let's make sure he's extra goofy so that ridiculous name and premise has no shot of being taken at all seriously, even by the other characters. Finally, we'll use some horrendous dialogue that had to be written deliberately to sound hip though there's no way no one could think that it even got beat up in the same neighborhood by “hip” just so all the readers walk away from each and every issue unable to even hope things could get better. Yeah, let's do that. I almost wonder if Tad didn't deliberately aim at that ice berg...and we're talking Titanic, not that cruise liner down in Antarctica.
I kinda have to stop there or my head might explode and then we wouldn't be much of a Cerberus, now would we? All that said, and I think it's pretty clear that there was no way sales would pick up, especially when someone like me – hooked on the series with the Busiek re-launch – gave deep thought to just dropping it all together before they made the decision for me. It's so annoying more because the series had great potential and in the space of 8 issues it was ruined. Here's hoping there'll be a re-re-launch that involves a tidal wave taking out a bookstore during a Tad Williams event...and no one investigating the cause.
So that's it for round one of the cenTramblings. Yeah, I decided on a name. Your contributions are of course still welcome. I just won't consider them. 'Til next time, I remain yours,
cenTrale



